This episode is another one of those insanely mythologically driven episodes. It’s mostly about Locke looking for Jacob’s Cabin but it also shows Locke’s life and some stuff on the Freighter.
On the Freighter we see Keamy prepare to carry out the Secondary Protocol. He also kills the doctor and scares everyone else. Sayid goes back to the island on the little Zodiac. Desmond decides to stay on the Freighter. Michael tries his best to save everyone on the island from Keamy.
In Locke’s flashback we see Richard stalking Locke, trying to recruit him, presumably to go to the island. In the first instant Richard observes Locke as a baby. In the second he tries to test him, Locke fails. In the third test Richard invites him from afar and Locke is too stubborn to accept. In the end it’s the opposing side (I assume) that gets to Locke. Abbadon visits Locke and encourages him to go on a Walkabout, if that solves Locke’s problem then Locke would owe him one. Scary stuff.
On the island Locke tries to track Jacob and his cabin. Horace visits him in a vision and tells Locke that if he finds Horace he will find Jacob. This leads Locke to the Dharma Ditch and a map to the Cabin. Locke find it and is met with Christian. Christian tells Locke to move the island and Claire smiles.
This episode has almost all of the power players in the show. Locke, Ben, Richard, Abbadon, Christian, Jacob. The only one missing is Charles Whidmore. That makes this episode good. Also the fact that it deals almost exclusively with the mythological side of the show makes it tops.
-Hey you can hear Daniel’s coded message coming over one of Keamy’s man’s phone. I guess that’s the time difference. It wasn’t too far off though, because a few scenes later the doctor is killed.
-I was so scared when Desmond decided to stay behind on The Freighter. That left him, Michael and a lot of extras. That’s a dangerous position to be in. Suddenly he was very vulnerable. I wanted him to stay with Sayid because I was absolutely sure that Sayid would stay alive long enough to get off the island.
-What if Hurley’s theory is right, what if the only reason why Locke and Hurley can see the cabin is because they’re insane(ish)? That would be depressing.
-I love it when Ben says that he’s been following Hurley. It shows what a terrible group they are. Ben is the only purpose with any iniative. Well, Locke is occasionally motivated, but usually for the wrong reasons.
-I love it when Ben says, “I used to have dreams”. It was so final, indicating that Locke had completely taken over his role.
-I also love it when Ben realizes that Locke is leading them to the Dharma ditch.
-Ben says it wasn’t his decision to wipe out the Dharma Initiative, it was The Hostile’s leaders who made that decision. Who are these leaders? $10 says we’ll learn who these leaders are in season 5.
-Ben’s eyes go huge (moreso) when he sees that Locke is searching Horace’s body.
-Ben says the Alex’s blood was all over his hands.
-”Destiny John is a fickle bitch.” They give Ben the best lines.
-Ben refused to go into the cabin. I think that was mostly bitterness though. I wonder if he would have seen through Christian’s trickery if he had gone in.
-I said this back in season 1 but I think that they did a great job of casting a young Emily (Locke’s mom).
-No wonder why Locke is so strange, his adoptive family seemed especially crazy.
-So Locke drew a picture of Smokey. I doubt that means anything more than that he’s special and belongs on the island.
-I don’t see why Richard would be against Locke choosing the knife. It’s not like Richard is the most peaceful character.
-Locke had a Geronimo Jackson poster in his locker, wasn’t he the one who said he didn’t know who they were.
-I laughed so hard when teenage Locke said that he liked “boxing”.
-It seems so obvious to me now, when I watch this episode, that Horace is Jacob.
-Hurley asks, “Who builds a cabin in the middle of the jungle?”
-Horace a has a nosebleed like Desmond did in The Constant. Possibly it’s a coincidence, writers like to use nosebleeds to indicate brain injuries.
-I wonder where Jacob was when Christian was in the cabin. I guess that’s the question of the hour isn’t it.
-When Richard shows up behind the glass I yelled with delight. It was just so wonderful to have him back. It also confirmed (hopefully) that he can live forever. (Isn’t it great that Cane was canceled?)
-I think it’s agreed that Richard was emulating the Dalai Lama inheritance ritual thing. If Locke had chosen items that the former “chosen one” had owned then he would have proved that he was the reincarnated person.
-Matthew Abbadon’s return was freaky, but not quite as exciting as Richard’s. I thought that he was the same black nurse guy from “The Man from Tallahassee”.
-I hope that Abbadon gets to come back in season 5, although it seems unlikely since the actor is on Fringe.
-I thought he was going to push Locke down the stairs.
-Did Abbadon orchestrate Locke’s arrival on the island? He sent him on the Walkabout, but that’s a lot of foreknowledge.
-So Locke’s going to owe Abbadon one. That could end badly. Perhaps he’ll kill Locke.
-I’m sure that Christian is bad now. somehow I didn’t see that before, but it seems very likely now. I would really like to know his motivation.
-The fact that he says that he can speak on Jacob’s behalf is obviously evil. There is no reason why Jacob wouldn’t be in his own cabin to speak to Locke.
-At the end of the cabin scene when Locke asks “how do I save the island?” Christian looks at Claire in a way that says “he’s fallen into our trap”.
-I wonder if Christian was trying to get Locke to turn the Frozen Donkey Wheel? That would have been the obvious thing to do.
-I think that they put Claire in the cabin for many reasons but one of those reasons was so that we’d trust Christian. Having her sit their happily makes us think that he’s just one of the gang. I know that the obvious reason is to get her out of the action for a while though. That was nice of the writers not to kill her (technically).
-Sayid looks a little regretful when he sees that Keamy is going to hurt or kill Keamy.
-I like that Frank tries to help Michael.
-Good for the Captain for doing the right thing, even if it was too late.
-I don’t think Keamy was prepared for Smokey.
-I knew that thing on Keamy’s arm was a dead-man’s switch they had those on Alias quite a few times. (It looks like a sattelite radio tuner though.)
-So Whidmore wrote the secondary protocol.
Flashbacks (what we knew then):
-I love the opening to this episode, but I do admit that it tricked me. I wasn’t sure if I was actually watching Lost when it came on. Great song too.
-At this point, and for most of season 4, I was betting that Sayid was in the coffin. It was wishful thinking though, I just wanted him dead.
Flashforwards (what we know now):