I expected to give this episode a 0.0 but I was surprised when I rewatched it. It is a bad episode but I had only remembered the awful parts. the flashback was most definitely irrelevant and annoying. The Sheriff, Isabelle was a waste of space and has no bearing on the story. Juliet’s court case was vague to the point of being useless. And the tease with Cindy and the kids was maddening.
Before I rewatched it I was willing to write this episode off as being non-canon in my mind.
But I was surprised. What I did like was the parts about Karl and Alex, and I especially like what Tom says to Jack about his perspective on The Others (see the Mr. Friendly section below for more info). The episode is probably still the worst episode ever, but at least it’s not a zero. 1.5/10.0
-Apparently the Sheriff would listen to anything Ben would say. I can understand that if Ben says that Jacob told him to say something, but it’s pretty crazy if Ben just has limitless executive power.
-It is so foreboding when they move Juliet in Jack’s old room.
-Juliet’s mark is just awful. I assume it just means she’s a murderer and it’s so that other Others can identify her and avoid her.
-The worst part about this flashback is that Jack doesn’t even get his whole tattoo done in this episode. If the writers were hoping to do more episodes about his tattoo that is just ridiculous.
-Karl, “God loves you as he loved Jacob.” It’s surprising that he actually said that, was he completely brainwashed.
-Kate asks about the kids that the Others took. Karl says that they took them away and gave them better lives.
-Poor Karl, if anyone ever caught me on the island crying I would really hope it wouldn’t be Sawyer.
-This episode has a great moment. Jack thinks that Mr. Friendly is going to take him out and kill him and he says that to him. Tom says, “What kind of people do you think we are, Jack?” Jack says, “well I don’t know Tom. The kind of people who would take a pregnant woman, who would hang Charlie from a tree, would drag our people out of the jungle, would kidnap our children. That’s the kind of people I think you are.” Mr. Friendly taps Jack’s glass wall, “You see this glass house you’re living in Jack? How ’bout I get you some stones.” He’s completely right. I’ve been saying it for quite some time, the survivors think that The Others are monsters, but statistically the survivors have killed more Others than the other way around.
-This is the worst character they have ever introduced into Lost. The way she delivers her lines is painful, she has this bored monotone way of talking. She just drives me crazy.
-At one time I thought that Isabelle was Smokey or Jacob. This was my way of making her more interesting. I’m pretty sure that has been proved wrong.
-Some good news about this character, I believe that Darlton said that she died in some sort of off-screen skirmish.
-Alex asks Jack why he saved Ben’s life. She actually wanted him to die, or at least she acts like it.
Flashbacks (what we knew then):
-Remember how I said that Nathan Fillion was one first times they used stunt casting in Lost and I liked it. Here’s a time when it really didn’t work. Bai Ling might have had a good role at one point, she’s very interesting looking, but come on her character was outrageous.
Flashforwards (what we know now):
-They put all of the kidnapped Tailies in front of Jack’s cage. They appear more than a little dazed. I’ve been told that they were all brainwashed in Room 23. I wouldn’t have come up with that on my own.
-Jack and Juliet’s romance is not supposed to be romantic at all. They were just on parallel paths for a certain amount of time, and they had a lot things in common.