I cried the first time I watched this episode, and I cried again when I rewatched it this time. This episode is glorious and a half. It manages to mix intense and confusing sci-fi with a perfectly written love story. Wow, I can’t tell you how much I love this episode.
And not only that but it includes all of my favorite characters. Desmond was my first favorite character and his love story with Penny was my favorite storyline. Then Daniel came along and I questioned my complete loyalty to Desmond. Now that Desmond and Penny’s love story is mostly over Daniel is my favorite character but I still love them all.
I also love sci-fi themes and I love how these writers do it. They insist on making it logical, which is reassuring and entertaining at the same time. It’s all great fun.
I also found out a lot by rewatching this episode. Like Locke’s possible fate, and the importance of nosebleeds.
If I could give it more than 10 I would. 10.0/10.0
-Daniel says that sometimes people can experience the “unstuck in time” phenomenon with a time differential of a few hours and sometimes it’s years. I’ll bet that it all depends upon how much radiation they were exposed to. Desmond was exposed to a lot, I would suspect that Daniel was too.
-Daniel asks Desmond the obvious question in the past. Why wouldn’t he remember their meeting? Desmond says, “maybe you just forgot,” Daniel responds, “Yeah, right, how would that happen?” If that’s not foreshadowing then I don’t know what is. Daniel most definitely has memory problems.
-Daniel reminds us (mostly me) that “you can’t change the future”. Except that I can think of someone who can, someone very special. (See Below)
-Daniel says that he wears a lead apron to protect from exposure to radiation, but I don’t think it works too well. I believe that Daniel was exposed to enough radiation to become unstuck in time if he ever tried to leave the island. (I don’t know why it wouldn’t effect him on the way in though, I’ll have to think about that.)
-I like that Daniel wears the same outfit in 1996 that he does in 2004. Hopefully he’s always worn that outfit, it makes those season 5 trailers less worrisome for me.
-Becoming unstuck in time seems like a good thing, besides the dying thing and the insanity that likely ensues. You would gain all of your future memories in your past body. You would become a genius, someone like… Daniel Faraday.
-Daniel choosing Desmond as his constant was very reassuring. It meant that the two characters would always need each other which is fortunate because they are my two favorite characters. It also means that at some point Daniel will get unstuck in time.
-The first “flashback” was so confusing, I just assumed it was a normal flashback, it seemed like it, but then he was the wrong Desmond, in the wrong time, it was mind-blowing.
-So the reason why Desmond was effected and Sayid and Frank weren’t was because Desmond was in the Hatch when it imploded. He was exposed to large amounts of electro-magnetic energy.
-Daniel never promises that Desmond will stop having these “flashbacks”. Even if he has his constant he could still be unstuck in time.
-WHOA! Hold on, Desmond’s nose starts bleeding near the end of his flashes. So that is what that means. Can you think of anyone else who has conspicuous nosebleeds? I can. (See below)
-Minowski says that Penny was constantly phoning the freighter. She was trying to contact them for some reason. Likely she found out about her father’s mission and wanted to try to get them to save Desmond. Or she was trying to find the location of the island too.
-Penny says that she was looking for the island, researching it, and that she knows about it. I wonder how much she knew? I imagine if she looked into her fathers past she could get a lot of info. But she must have other sources.
-Locke was the only other person who was exposed to the same amount of electro-magnetic energy as Desmond. So if Locke ever tries to leave the island he will experience the same “unstuck in time” phenomenon. There’s something to look forward to.
-I feel so sorry for Sayid. He has no idea what’s going on for this entire episode.
-Frank tried his best to fly on a bearing of exactly 305, and he was only off by a degree or two by the storm. That wasn’t the problem, was it? Daniel said it was because of the large amount of radiation that Desmond was exposed to.
-Keamy seems positively harmless in the beginning of this episode.
-Keamy and the doctor both try their hardest to keep Desmond from talking to Daniel. They probably all think that he’s crazy. I think that Charlotte was the only person who actually believed in him.
-Minkowski seemed like such an important character. I hope we get to see him again at some point.
-Minkowski when on a raft to go see the island. Sad.
-This guys neck is so tiny.
-When Whidmore buys the the journal of the Black Rock, they say that no one knows what it says. It must be an interesting story.
-Desmond asks why Charles hates him so much and Whidmore responds cryptically, “It’s not me who hates you.” Who could it be, Penny? Jacob? God? Fate?
Flashbacks (what we knew then):
-I was very reassured when I saw the freighter. Hearing that it was there and seeing it were two very different things, and frankly I wasn’t sure it was real until I saw it.
-This episode was exhilarating to watch. The pace in incomparable, and the ending is perfect.
Flashforwards (what we know now):
-I believe that Walt can change the future, which goes against what Daniel said, but Daniel doesn’t know how special Walt is. See my theory here: Walt’s Powers. I should say that I believe that Walt can change the past and effect the future, which is the same thing as changing the future, just with more words.
-Later in season 4 we see a vision of Locke’s where he meets Horace, and his nose is bleeding. Could that signify that he became unstuck in time? This is all very surprising.